This sifi film with aliens living in a slum in Johannisburg is quite original. The
plot is inventive, though the script comes across a bit crude. I feel like
there were many opportunities to draw parallels between the events on screen
and past or present situations in the real world, but any hint at a reflection
on actual history was quickly disfigured by the illogical extremes the people
in the film went to.
The main
character benefited from excellent casting – Sharlton Copley pulled off the dumb-looking
paper-pusher just as well as the disillusioned and traumatised victim – but is
not someone to get behind easily. Still, he is interesting. At first, it’s easy
to mistake him for a half-wit who just loves to live by the rules, but he soon
displays competence. However, even after suffering trauma and a reality check
regarding the true nature of his employer, he does not magically turn into a
good person. He still follows questionable motivations that in his head clearly
seem completely natural. Only at the very end of the film does he begin to
truly change – in more ways than one. It’s refreshing to see an anti-hero lead
the story, someone you not quite hate but also don’t feel particularly drawn
to.
The other characters in the film suffer from bad writing. All of them
just seem inhuman, and it makes you wonder whether this whole situation with
the alien “guests” and constantly being surrounded by crime in South Africa
made them that way, or if it’s just incompetent writing. The aliens don’t make
much sense at all. They seem of fairly low intelligence, which makes the one
smart individual seem very incongruous. Still, low intelligence or not, they
are clearly sentient, so it does not make any sense at all why there are no
diplomatic efforts under way.
The visuals
were remarkable, particularly considering this film is a staggering 11 years
old! They chose a colour palette and a type of grainy filter that masked the
CGI and creature effects very well making everything blend together perfectly. Good editing and prosthetics did the rest. Certainly a technically challenging project, but they
took it on with great success. The only bit I could really have done without
was the copious and gory violence.
A difficult
piece to judge. Surprising in its originality, impressive in its visual
execution, but with a story that did not really seem to fulfil its potential
and puzzling characters that prevent the audience from truly empathising. 4/5
for effort.
District 9 on Imdb